Hungary’s Prime Minister Discusses Peace With Putin; Outcry from EU

On Friday, July 5, 2024, Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orban met with Vladimir Putin to discuss a peace deal that upset the European Union, who cautioned Hungary against appeasing Moscow. The E.U. stated that Prime Minister Orban does not speak to President Putin on behalf of the European Union. On Monday, July 1, 2024, Hungary assumed a six-month rotating president. Five days after this, Orban visited Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskiy in Kyiv, during which Orban formed a new alliance with other right-wing nationalists, the Patriots for Europe Alliance. The meeting between Orban and Putin was the first meeting Putin had with an E.U. leader in Moscow since April 2022, which was merely two months after Moscow launched its attack on Ukraine. Putin has stated that talks with Prime Minister Orban were productive, however, he said that his ideas about a potential resolution were the right way to move forward, and accused Ukraine of not wanting to end the conflict. 

According to the European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen, “Only unity and determination within the 27-nation E.U. would pave the way to a just and lasting peace in Ukraine. Appeasement won’t stop Putin.” Putin disagreed with this statement, arguing that “I have repeatedly said that we have always been and remain open to discussing a political and diplomatic settlement. However, on the other side of the conflict, we hear about the reluctance to resolve issues in this particular way.” A diplomat from the European Nations described that “Orban’s trip meant that skepticism within the bloc about Hungary’s presidency was unfortunately justified – it’s all about promoting Budapest’s interests.” The Lithuanian President Gitanas Nauseda also weighed in on Hungary’s talk with Russia, arguing that Orban was undermining the E.U. presidency. “If you truly seek peace, you don’t shake hands with a bloody dictator, you put all your efforts to support Ukraine,” Nauseda accused. 

Prime Minister Orban’s actions have not been well-received by many European Union leaders and officials, who view them as undermining the bloc’s unified stance on Ukraine. The fear is that Orban’s visit could be perceived as appeasement, potentially emboldening Putin and weakening the E.U.’s collective bargaining position. The criticism from other E.U. leaders, such as Estonian Prime Minister Kaja Kallas and Lithuanian President Gitanas Nauseda, reflects a broader concern that Orban’s trip might sow confusion and division within the E.U. Their emphasis on supporting Ukraine and rejecting any engagement with Putin as a peace-seeking measure underscores a commitment to solidarity with Ukraine and a firm stance against Russia’s aggression. While Orban’s initiative to engage in dialogue is commendable from a diplomatic perspective, it is essential to balance such efforts with the need for a united front within the E.U. 

Viktor Orban has pursued a policy of balancing Hungary’s commitments to the E.U. and N.A.T.O. with maintaining a cooperative relationship with Russia. This has included energy deals, such as agreements on nuclear energy and natural gas, and frequent diplomatic engagements with Putin. Relations between the E.U. and Russia significantly deteriorated following Russia’s annexation of Crimea in 2014 and its support for separatist movements in Eastern Ukraine. Hungary’s assumption of the rotating E.U. presidency in July 2024 places it in a prominent position within the E.U., potentially allowing Orban to influence E.U. policy more directly. Orban’s government has often been at odds with mainstream E.U. policies, particularly regarding its stance on Russia and Ukraine. Orban’s visit to Moscow and his discussions with Putin come at a sensitive time, with the ongoing conflict in Ukraine and strong E.U. support for Ukraine’s sovereignty and territorial integrity. Orban’s actions have raised concerns among E.U. leaders about the potential for disunity and the risk of undermining the E.U.’s collective stance on the conflict.

Prime Minister Viktor Orban’s meeting with President Vladimir Putin on July 5, 2024, to discuss a potential peace deal for Ukraine has triggered significant backlash from the European Union. Critics argue that Orban’s actions may sow confusion and division within the E.U., potentially weakening its collective bargaining position. The Hungarian Prime Minister’s diplomatic endeavours, while intended to foster dialogue, must navigate the complex dynamics of maintaining E.U. solidarity and adhering to the principle of supporting Ukraine’s sovereignty and territorial integrity. As Hungary’s presidency continues, the E.U. faces the challenge of ensuring that its collective stance on the Ukraine conflict remains strong and coherent, while addressing the internal disagreements that Orban’s actions have brought to the forefront. 

Related